Acetone To Remove Paint: Is It Effective?

Acetone, a potent solvent, has the capability to dissolve various substances. Paint, when applied to metal surfaces, often creates a durable coating. The effectiveness of acetone in removing paint depends on the paint type and the metal’s properties. The success of using acetone as a paint remover is subject to factors, including the duration of exposure and the method of application.

Alright, let’s dive into the wonderful world of acetone! You might know it as that nail polish remover sitting in your bathroom cabinet, but trust me, it’s got way more tricks up its sleeve. We’re talking about a powerful solvent that can actually make paint vanish before your very eyes.

Think of acetone as the underdog of the paint removal game – readily available, surprisingly effective, but also a bit of a wildcard if you don’t know how to handle it.

Contents

What Exactly Is Acetone?

Acetone is a colorless liquid that smells kind of sweet, and it’s fantastic at dissolving things. You’ll find it in all sorts of products, from cosmetics to cleaners, thanks to its solvent powers. But today, we’re honing in on its superpower: paint removal. It’s like the Clark Kent of chemicals, just waiting to be unleashed on stubborn paint.

Paint’s Worst Nightmare

Now, you might be thinking, “Paint removal? Really?” Absolutely! Acetone is a frequent application choice for this task. Whether you’re sprucing up an old piece of furniture or tackling a DIY project gone wrong, acetone can be your secret weapon.

What We’re Covering

In this article, we’re going to walk you through everything you need to know about using acetone for paint removal. We’ll cover:

  • How effective acetone is on different types of paint
  • Crucial safety considerations
  • Step-by-step instructions for successful paint removal
  • And, of course, we’ll touch on alternative methods if acetone isn’t quite the right fit for your project.

So, buckle up, grab your safety goggles (seriously, grab them!), and let’s get started!

What is Acetone? Unlocking Its Solvent Superpowers

Alright, let’s get a bit nerdy (but in a fun way, I promise!). Acetone, chemically known as propanone, is a colorless liquid that smells kinda sweet (but don’t go tasting it!). It’s a powerful solvent, meaning it’s really good at dissolving other substances. Think of it like the popular kid in the chemical world, always hanging out and breaking down barriers between different materials.

But how does it actually work its magic? Well, acetone has a special molecular structure that allows it to interact with both polar and non-polar substances. This is key because paint is made up of a whole bunch of different ingredients, some polar, some not so much. Acetone essentially swoops in and breaks those ingredients apart, loosening the paint’s grip on whatever surface it’s clinging to. And because Acetone is considered a volatile organic compound (VOC), it evaporates quickly.

Cracking the Code: Acetone and Different Paint Types

Now, let’s talk compatibility! Not all paints are created equal, and acetone has its favorites. Let’s break it down:

  • Oil-Based Paint: Acetone generally works pretty well on oil-based paints, especially if the paint job isn’t too old. It can soften the paint and make it easier to scrape away.

  • Latex Paint: Acetone can have some effect on latex paints, especially thinner coats or when combined with some elbow grease but not as powerful as Oil-based

  • Acrylic Paint: Similar to latex, acetone might soften acrylic paint, but it’s often not the most effective choice. You might need more aggressive solvents or methods.

  • Enamel Paint: Enamel paints can be tricky. Acetone might work on thinner or newer coats, but tougher enamels might require stronger stuff.

  • Epoxy Paint: Forget about it! Acetone is usually no match for epoxy paints. These are super durable and resistant to most solvents. You’ll need specialized epoxy strippers.

  • Lacquer Paint: Ah, now we’re talking! Acetone is often quite effective at dissolving lacquer paints, which is why it’s frequently used in lacquer thinners.

Layer Upon Layer: The Paint Obstacle Course

Think of paint like an onion – lots of layers! The more layers you have, the harder acetone has to work. Each layer of paint acts as a barrier, slowing down the solvent’s progress.

And then there’s the primer. Primer is like the paint’s bodyguard, designed to create a strong bond between the surface and the topcoat. Some primers are more resistant to acetone than others. A tough primer can significantly hinder acetone’s ability to reach and dissolve the paint above it. So, be prepared for a bit of a challenge if you’re dealing with multiple layers and a stubborn primer!

Surface Matters: Preparing and Protecting Various Materials

Alright, let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of how acetone plays with different surfaces. Think of it like introducing a new friend—you want to make sure they get along with everyone else at the party, right? Same goes for acetone. It’s crucial to know how it interacts with metal, wood, and plastic to avoid any unpleasant surprises.

Acetone Application on Different Surfaces

  • Metal Surfaces:

    Metal is tough, but not invincible. Acetone can be a great ally in stripping paint, but let’s break down the specifics:

    • Steel: Steel and acetone generally play nice, but be aware that prolonged exposure could lead to rust if the protective coatings are stripped away. It’s like leaving it out in the rain without an umbrella! After using acetone, make sure to neutralize and protect the steel to prevent corrosion.

    • Aluminum: Aluminum is a bit more sensitive. While acetone can remove paint, it’s crucial to work quickly and not let the acetone sit for too long. Prolonged exposure can cause discoloration or a dull finish. Think of it as a quick handshake, not a long hug!

    • Iron: Similar to steel, iron can rust if left unprotected. Acetone will remove the paint, but immediate post-treatment is necessary. Apply a rust inhibitor or primer ASAP to keep that iron looking sharp.

    • Copper: Copper is a diva! It can react with acetone, leading to discoloration or even etching if you’re not careful. Always test in an inconspicuous area first, and don’t let the acetone linger. A quick wipe-down is usually best.

  • Wood Surfaces:

    Ah, wood, the classic canvas. But it’s also porous and absorbent, which means acetone can penetrate deeply.

    • Consider the type of wood: Hardwoods like oak or maple can handle acetone better than softwoods like pine. But always work in a well-ventilated area and avoid soaking the wood. If you are refinishing a piece of furniture, take extra caution and always test it somewhere unnoticeable first.
    • Apply a neutralizing agent after the acetone treatment to prevent any unwanted reactions.
  • Plastic Surfaces:

    Be extra cautious when using acetone on plastic. Many plastics will melt, dissolve, or become permanently discolored. Always, always test in an inconspicuous area first! If the plastic starts to feel soft or sticky, stop immediately. Some plastics, like certain acrylics, can handle acetone briefly, but it’s a risky game.

Preparing the Surface for Acetone

Preparation is key! Think of it like prepping a canvas before painting—a clean slate ensures the best results.

  • Cleaning the surface before applying acetone: Get rid of any loose debris, dirt, or grime. A simple wipe-down with soap and water can work wonders. This ensures the acetone can directly target the paint, not the gunk on top.
  • Neutralizing and cleaning steps to take after paint removal: Once the paint is gone, it’s time to clean up the mess. A neutralizing agent (like a mild detergent solution) can help stop any further chemical reactions. Rinse thoroughly with water and dry the surface completely. For metal, consider applying a protective coating to prevent rust. For wood, you might want to sand lightly and apply a primer before refinishing.

The Acetone Paint Removal Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

Alright, let’s get down to brass tacks! You’ve decided to wrestle that stubborn paint off with acetone? Smart choice! But before we dive in, let’s make sure you’re armed and ready. Think of this section as your treasure map to a paint-free paradise.

Materials Needed

First, gather your gear. Imagine yourself as a paint-busting superhero, and these are your tools:

  • Acetone: Not all acetone is created equal! You’ll generally find it in varying concentrations. For most household paint removal, the standard stuff will do the trick. However, for really tough cases, you might consider a more potent, industrial-grade option. Just remember, with great power comes great responsibility. Higher concentrations mean more intense fumes and potential hazards, so proceed with caution!
  • Rags/Cloths: Think absorbency, not abrasion. Old cotton t-shirts, microfiber cloths – these are your friends. Avoid anything that might dissolve or react with acetone. You don’t want to end up with a sticky, lint-covered mess.
  • Brushes: For the nooks and crannies where rags can’t reach, a good brush is essential. Opt for natural bristle brushes or those specifically designed for solvents. Cheap plastic brushes might melt or disintegrate – not the kind of abstract art we’re going for.
  • Gloves: Chemical-resistant is the name of the game. Nitrile or neoprene gloves are your best bet. Acetone can dry out and irritate your skin faster than a desert wind, so protect those precious hands!
  • Eye Protection: Safety goggles, folks! Not your everyday sunglasses. Acetone fumes can irritate your eyes, and a splash could cause serious damage. Goggles that seal snugly around your eyes are crucial.
  • Respirator/Ventilation: This is non-negotiable. Acetone fumes are no joke. Work in a well-ventilated area, or better yet, wear a respirator specifically designed for organic vapors. Your lungs will thank you!

Application Process

Alright, you’ve got your gear. Let’s get this paint off!

  • Applying Acetone to the Paint: Liberally apply acetone to the painted surface. You can use a rag, brush, or even a spray bottle for larger areas. The key is to saturate the paint thoroughly.
  • Soak Time: Patience, young padawan! This is where the magic happens. Let the acetone sit for a bit to work its dissolving powers. Soak time varies depending on the type of paint. Oil-based paints may need a longer soak (15-30 minutes), while thinner layers of latex or acrylic might only need 5-10 minutes. Keep an eye on it – you want the paint to soften, not dry out.
  • Agitation: Once the paint is softened, it’s time to scrub! Use a clean rag or brush to gently scrub the surface. For stubborn areas, try using a plastic scraper (metal can scratch the surface). Avoid excessive force, as you don’t want to damage the underlying material.

Post-Application

Huzzah! You’ve banished the paint! But the job’s not quite done yet.

  • Cleaning the Surface: Now, you have to get rid of all traces of acetone and loosened paint. Wipe the surface thoroughly with a clean, damp rag. Soap and water can help, but make sure to completely remove all soap residue as well.
  • Waste Disposal: This is super important. Acetone-soaked rags are a fire hazard! Allow them to air dry completely outdoors before disposing of them in a sealed metal container. Contact your local waste management authority for specific guidelines on disposing of hazardous materials. Don’t just toss them in the trash!

Safety First: Handling Acetone Responsibly

Okay, folks, let’s get real about something super important: safety! We’re talking about acetone, which is like that one friend who’s awesome at getting things done but needs a little supervision. We’re diving deep into how to use it without, you know, accidentally turning your garage into a chemistry experiment gone wrong. Safety glasses on, gloves ready—let’s do this!

Handling Acetone Safely

  • Gloves and Eye Protection: Your New Best Friends:

    Seriously, don’t even think about skipping this. Imagine acetone getting in your eyes – not a good look (or feeling!). We’re talking chemical-resistant gloves here, people, not your grandma’s gardening gloves. Think nitrile or neoprene. As for eye protection, grab those safety goggles that wrap around your eyes like they’re giving them a hug. No peeking allowed!

  • Respirator/Ventilation: Clearing the Air:

    Ever walked into a room and thought, “Whoa, what’s that smell?” That’s probably not a good sign when you’re dealing with acetone. You need airflow, my friends! We’re talking open windows, fans blowing, maybe even a full-blown respirator if you’re tackling a big project indoors. Don’t underestimate the power of fresh air. If you start feeling dizzy, lightheaded, or just plain weird, step away and get some ventilation immediately.

Flammability Hazards: Playing with Fire (Figuratively, Not Literally!)

  • Understanding Acetone’s Flammability and Flashpoint:

    Here’s the deal: acetone is super flammable. Like, campfire-in-a-dry-forest flammable. The “flashpoint” is the lowest temperature at which it can form a vapor that ignites. Think about that for a second. Keep it away from open flames, sparks, and anything that gets hot. No smoking, no welding, no spontaneous combustion experiments, okay?

  • Preventive Measures to Avoid Fires and Explosions:

    This is where we get serious. Store acetone in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight and heat sources. Use it in a well-ventilated area, and never near an open flame or anything that could spark. And for the love of all that is holy, don’t pour it down the drain or toss acetone-soaked rags into a pile. Those rags can spontaneously combust, which is a fancy way of saying “burst into flames out of nowhere.” Instead, spread them out to dry in a safe place before tossing them out, or better yet, soak them in water before disposal. Seriously, treat this stuff with respect, and it’ll respect you back (by not setting your garage on fire).

Troubleshooting: When Things Don’t Go According to Plan (Because Let’s Be Honest, They Rarely Do)

Alright, so you’ve bravely ventured into the world of acetone-fueled paint removal. You’re feeling confident, maybe even a little bit like a mad scientist. But what happens when things don’t go exactly as planned? Don’t panic! We’ve all been there. Let’s tackle some common hiccups and how to fix them. Think of this as your acetone first-aid kit.

Damage to the Underlying Metal/Surface: “Oops, I Did It Again”

  • Prevention is better than cure, as your grandma probably told you. So, how do we prevent accidental surface carnage in the first place? Before you douse your precious item in acetone, do a small, inconspicuous test spot. This helps you gauge how the surface reacts. Also, remember that less is more. Start with light applications and gradually increase as needed. Don’t go full-on Niagara Falls of acetone right away!

  • Metal Mishaps: If you’re working with metal, certain types might react poorly to prolonged acetone exposure. Always check for discoloration, pitting, or weakening. For aluminum, especially, be vigilant.

  • Wood Woes: With wood, the biggest danger is drying out. Acetone can strip away natural oils, leading to cracking. Consider applying a wood conditioner or oil immediately after cleaning to replenish moisture.

  • Plastic Problems: Acetone can dissolve or warp some plastics faster than you can say “uh-oh.” If you absolutely must use it on plastic, proceed with extreme caution. Short contact times and thorough rinsing are key!

  • Addressing the Damage: Okay, so you’ve got some damage. Now what?

    • Minor Discoloration/Etching: Polishing compounds can often buff out minor imperfections on metal or plastic.
    • Wood Cracking: Wood fillers or epoxy resins can patch cracks. Sand smooth and refinish.
    • Severe Damage: Sometimes, the damage is beyond repair. Know when to throw in the towel. It might be better to replace the affected part than to keep fighting a losing battle.

Residue: The Ghost of Paint Past

  • Dealing with that annoying, sticky film that acetone sometimes leaves behind? That’s residue, and it’s not your friend. The key is understanding why it’s there in the first place. Usually, it’s either leftover paint pigment or impurities in the acetone itself.

  • Effective Cleaning Methods:

    • Fresh Acetone Rinse: Sometimes, a simple rinse with clean acetone will do the trick. Make sure you’re using a fresh, uncontaminated batch.
    • Soapy Water: After the acetone, a good wash with mild soap and water can help remove any lingering residue.
    • Specialized Cleaners: For particularly stubborn residue, consider using a specialized cleaner designed for the material you’re working with (metal cleaner, wood cleaner, etc.).
    • The Power of Scrubbing (Gently): A soft-bristled brush or a non-abrasive sponge can help lift residue without scratching the surface.
    • Microfiber Magic: Microfiber cloths are excellent for picking up even the tiniest particles of residue.

    Remember to always test your cleaning method in an inconspicuous area first!

By keeping these troubleshooting tips in mind, you can tackle most acetone-related paint removal challenges with confidence (and maybe a little bit of humor). Happy paint-removing!

Beyond Acetone: Exploring Alternative Paint Removal Methods

Okay, so acetone’s not always the shiny knight in paint-removal armor. Sometimes, you need to call in the reserves. Let’s peek at some other options for bidding adieu to unwanted paint, each with its own quirks and perks.

Other Solvents

Sometimes, acetone alone just isn’t enough to do the job.

  • Paint Thinner: Think of paint thinner as acetone’s milder cousin.
    • Pros: It’s often less harsh, making it a better choice for delicate surfaces. Plus, it’s generally more budget-friendly.
    • Cons: It might take longer and require more elbow grease. And it may not be as effective on tougher paints.
    • Best Uses: Great for thinning oil-based paints (hence the name!) and cleaning brushes. Can work on fresh paint spills.
  • Mineral Spirits: Another mild option that’s similar to paint thinner but often has less odor.
    • Pros: Lower odor makes it a winner for indoor projects. Also relatively gentle.
    • Cons: Like paint thinner, it may struggle with stubborn or multiple layers of paint.
    • Best Uses: Cleaning, degreasing, and thinning oil-based paints. A good all-around solvent for general cleanup.
  • Lacquer Thinner: Now we’re getting a bit stronger. Lacquer thinner is more potent than paint thinner and mineral spirits.
    • Pros: Effective on lacquer finishes, which are notoriously tough. Dries quickly.
    • Cons: It’s a harsh solvent with strong fumes, so ventilation is a must. Can damage some plastics.
    • Best Uses: Thinning lacquer, cleaning lacquer spraying equipment, and removing lacquer finishes.
  • MEK (Methyl Ethyl Ketone): This is the heavy hitter of the group. MEK is seriously powerful.
    • Pros: Dissolves a wide range of paints, adhesives, and coatings. Works quickly.
    • Cons: Highly flammable and has strong, potentially harmful fumes. Requires extreme caution and excellent ventilation. It can also damage many materials.
    • Safety Concerns: Use only with proper training, ventilation, and personal protective equipment (gloves, respirator, eye protection). Consult safety data sheets (SDS) before use.
    • Best Uses: In industrial settings or for very tough coatings where other solvents have failed and proper safety measures can be implemented.

Mechanical Methods

Time to get a little physical! Sometimes brute force is what you need.

  • Sanding: The old reliable.
    • When It’s Appropriate: When you need to create a smooth surface for repainting, or when chemical methods are not suitable.
    • How to Do It Safely: Wear a dust mask to protect your lungs. Use the correct grit sandpaper for the job. Start with a coarser grit and gradually move to finer grits.
  • Scraping: A simple but effective method for removing loose or peeling paint.
    • Tools: Use a good-quality paint scraper with a comfortable handle. Consider different blade shapes for various surfaces and angles.
    • Techniques: Hold the scraper at a slight angle and apply even pressure. Work in small sections and avoid gouging the surface.
  • Heat Gun: Melting away the problem.
    • How to Use Safely and Effectively: Keep the heat gun moving to avoid scorching the surface. Work in well-ventilated area, as heating paint can release fumes. Use a scraper to remove the softened paint. Wear heat-resistant gloves.

Chemical Strippers

A sort of “paint removal smoothie” that works to remove anything that acetone cant remove itself.

  • Types: There are many chemical strippers on the market, including liquid, gel, and paste formulations. Some are designed for specific types of paint or surfaces.
  • Uses: Use chemical strippers when you need to remove multiple layers of paint or when mechanical methods are too difficult or time-consuming.
  • Safety Considerations: Chemical strippers can contain harsh chemicals, so always wear appropriate protective gear (gloves, eye protection, respirator). Work in well-ventilated area and follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. Dispose of used stripper and waste materials properly.

Environmental Responsibility: Minimizing Your Impact

  • Environmental Considerations: Acetone as a VOC

    • Okay, let’s get real about acetone and the environment. You know that faint, sweet smell when you’re using acetone? That’s a clue! Acetone is a VOC—a Volatile Organic Compound. Basically, it means that when acetone evaporates, it releases gases into the atmosphere. Now, before you panic and swear off DIY projects forever, let’s understand the impact.
    • VOCs can contribute to air pollution and, in some cases, smog formation. The good news is that acetone is considered to have a relatively low environmental impact compared to some other solvents. However, that doesn’t give us a free pass to be careless! It just means we need to be conscious about how we use and dispose of it. Think of it like this: a little sprinkle of glitter isn’t a big deal, but dumping a whole jar of it? Yeah, that’s going to cause some sparkly chaos.
  • Responsible Disposal and Usage Practices

    • Alright, so how do we minimize our acetone footprint? Here are some guidelines:

      • Use it Sparingly: Don’t go overboard with the acetone. Use just enough to get the job done. More isn’t always better, especially when it comes to solvents.
      • Ventilation is Key: Always work in a well-ventilated area. Open windows, turn on a fan, or work outside if possible. The goal is to prevent the build-up of acetone vapors.
      • Proper Storage: Store acetone in a tightly sealed container in a cool, dry place. This helps prevent evaporation and accidental spills.
      • Don’t Just Dump It! Under no circumstances should you pour acetone down the drain or into the environment. Seriously, don’t do it! Instead, check your local regulations for hazardous waste disposal. Many communities have designated collection sites where you can safely dispose of solvents like acetone.
      • Evaporation Method (Use with Caution): A method for small quantities: allow the acetone to evaporate completely in a well-ventilated area away from any source of ignition. This should only be done with small amounts and under controlled conditions to minimize environmental impact. Once the acetone has fully evaporated, the remaining solids can usually be disposed of as regular waste. However, double-check local regulations to be absolutely sure.
      • Soak It Up: When cleaning up spills, use absorbent materials like paper towels or rags. Allow these to dry completely in a well-ventilated area before disposing of them according to local regulations.
      • Consider Alternatives: For some tasks, you might be able to use alternative, more environmentally friendly paint removal methods. We’ll talk about those later in the article!
    • Remember, being environmentally responsible isn’t about being perfect; it’s about making smart choices and doing our best to minimize our impact. By following these tips, you can remove paint like a pro while also being a friend to Mother Nature. High five!

Real-World Applications: Acetone’s Paint-Busting Adventures!

Ever wondered where acetone really shines outside the lab? It’s not just for nail polish, folks! Let’s dive into some real-world scenarios where acetone steps up as the MVP of paint removal. Prepare for tales of automotive makeovers, furniture flips, and DIY victories!

Automotive Restoration: Reviving Rides with a Splash of Acetone

Picture this: a classic car, layers of tired paint clinging to its glory days. Acetone to the rescue! In automotive restoration, acetone is like a secret weapon. It’s used to gently lift away old paint from metal surfaces, prepping them for a fresh coat.

  • Examples: Removing faded paint from vintage cars, cleaning painted emblems.
  • Specific Techniques: Applying acetone with a rag to small areas, carefully monitoring to prevent damage to underlying surfaces. The key here is patience – don’t rush the process!

Furniture Refinishing: From Drab to Fab with a Wipe

Got an old dresser that’s seen better days? Maybe a chair that’s screaming for a makeover? Acetone can be your furniture’s new best friend. It helps strip away old finishes, revealing the beautiful wood beneath, ready for a fresh stain or paint job.

  • Examples: Removing varnish from antique tables, stripping paint from wooden chairs.
  • Specific Techniques: Lightly applying acetone to the surface, using a scraper to gently lift the softened paint. Pro Tip: Always test in an inconspicuous area first!

DIY Projects: Unleashing Your Inner Artist (Without the Mess)

For DIY enthusiasts, acetone is a versatile tool. Whether you’re upcycling, crafting, or just fixing things around the house, it can help remove unwanted paint spills and prepare surfaces for your next creative endeavor.

  • Examples: Cleaning paint off hinges and hardware, removing spray paint from stencils.
  • Specific Techniques: Using a cotton swab or small brush to apply acetone to targeted areas, followed by a gentle wipe with a clean cloth. Remember, a little goes a long way, and safety always comes first!

What factors determine acetone’s effectiveness in removing paint from metal surfaces?

Acetone demonstrates effectiveness on certain types of paint. The solvent properties of acetone dissolve specific chemical bonds in paint. Certain paints exhibit greater susceptibility to acetone. The age of paint affects the ease of removal. Fresh paint softens more readily compared to old paint. The thickness of paint layers influences removal efficiency. Thin layers dissolve faster than thick layers. Metal type impacts the outcome of paint removal. Some metals withstand acetone better than others.

How does acetone interact with different types of metal when removing paint?

Acetone interacts differently with various metals. The chemical resistance of metal determines interaction type. Certain metals show high resistance to acetone. Steel generally withstands acetone without significant corrosion. Aluminum might experience surface changes upon exposure. The duration of acetone exposure affects the metal surface. Prolonged exposure can cause unwanted effects. Careful monitoring of metal condition is therefore important.

What safety measures should be taken when using acetone to remove paint from metal?

Safety constitutes an important aspect when handling acetone. Ventilation minimizes inhalation risks during usage. Adequate airflow reduces concentration of acetone vapors. Protective gloves prevent skin contact. The chemical composition of gloves resists acetone’s solvent action. Eye protection safeguards against splashes and fumes. Safety goggles provide a reliable barrier. Respiratory masks filter out harmful vapors. The selection of mask depends on ventilation conditions.

What are the alternative methods for removing paint from metal if acetone is ineffective?

Alternative methods exist for paint removal from metal. Chemical strippers offer a potent alternative approach. Their formulation includes stronger solvents than those in acetone. Mechanical methods involve physical removal of paint. Sanding or scraping achieves paint removal. Thermal methods employ heat to soften paint. Heat guns or controlled heating facilitates scraping. Abrasive blasting utilizes media to strip paint. Sand, glass beads, or other materials propel against the surface.

So, next time you’ve got a metal surface marred by unwanted paint, don’t panic! A little acetone might just be your new best friend. Just remember to take those safety precautions seriously, and you’ll be stripping paint like a pro in no time. Happy DIY-ing!

Leave a Comment