Edge Joints: Create Wider Wood Surfaces

Edge-to-edge joints represent fundamental configurations in woodworking that connect two pieces of wood along their edges to create wider surfaces. Carpenters frequently use the technique in projects ranging from cabinet door construction to wide panel creation. Glue plays an important role in edge-to-edge joints because it ensures structural integrity by bonding surfaces tightly and evenly. Various woodworking joints achieve seamless and durable results depending on specific project requirements.

Let’s be honest, who hasn’t stared longingly at a beautiful, wide tabletop and wondered how it was made? The secret, my friends, often lies in the humble yet mighty edge-to-edge joint. Think of it as the woodworking world’s equivalent to a perfectly executed high-five – when done right, it’s a thing of beauty!

These joints are your ticket to creating wider panels from narrower boards, unlocking a whole new world of possibilities. Need a stunning tabletop for your dining room? Edge-to-edge joints are your answer. Dreaming of elegant cabinet sides, sturdy doors, or custom shelves? You guessed it – edge-to-edge joints to the rescue!

From crafting exquisite furniture to tackling various woodworking endeavors, this technique is an absolute must-have in your arsenal. This guide will arm you with the knowledge to conquer various joint types, choose the perfect adhesives, master essential techniques, and adopt best practices that will transform your projects. Say goodbye to flimsy, unsightly seams and hello to rock-solid, visually stunning results!

Contents

Understanding the Fundamentals of Edge-to-Edge Joints

Alright, let’s dive into the heart of what makes an edge-to-edge joint either a smashing success or a complete face-plant. It’s not just slapping two boards together and hoping for the best – there’s a bit more finesse involved. Think of it like baking: you can’t just throw ingredients together and expect a perfect cake, right?

First up, we’ve got the crucial factors that can make or break your joint. These are the non-negotiables, the things you absolutely must get right. Ignoring them is like willingly stepping into a woodworking comedy of errors.

The Holy Trinity: Grain, Alignment, and Pressure

  • Grain Direction: Think of wood grain like the strands of a muscle. You want those muscles working together, not against each other. Ideally, you want the grain of adjacent boards running in a similar direction. This helps with even expansion/contraction and prevents weird stresses. Visualize it: you don’t want one board pulling against its neighbor!

  • Alignment: Imagine trying to build a house with slightly crooked bricks. Eventually, the whole thing’s gonna look a bit wonky. Same goes for your edge joints! Perfect alignment is key to a smooth, professional-looking surface. This means edges are flush, without any embarrassing ledges or gaps.

  • Adequate Clamping Pressure: Okay, so you’ve got the right glue, the grain’s aligned, and everything looks perfect… but you skimp on the clamps? Big mistake! Clamping provides the necessary pressure to squeeze out excess glue and ensure a tight bond. Think of it as giving your joint a big, reassuring hug until the glue sets.

The Wood Movement Tango

Now, let’s talk about the elephant in the room: wood movement. Wood is a living, breathing material, and it’s constantly expanding and contracting with changes in humidity. Ignore this at your peril!

  • Expansion and Contraction: Wood absorbs moisture from the air, causing it to swell. Conversely, it loses moisture in dry conditions, causing it to shrink. This movement is mostly across the grain (width), which is what affects our edge joints.

  • Accounting for Wood Movement: So, how do we deal with this pesky movement?

    • Acclimatization: Let your wood acclimate to your shop’s environment for a week or two before working with it. This allows it to reach a stable moisture content.
    • Joint Design: Wide panels glued edge-to-edge act as a single wide board. Allow space for expansion and contraction, or use a breadboard end or other flexible joint to control the movement.
    • Finishing: Applying a finish helps slow down moisture absorption and loss, which can minimize wood movement.

Ignoring wood movement is like building a house on a fault line – it might look great at first, but eventually, things are going to shift. Understand these fundamental principles, and you’ll be well on your way to creating edge-to-edge joints that are not only strong and beautiful but also built to last.

Exploring Different Types of Edge-to-Edge Joints

Alright, let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of joining those board edges! You’ve got options, my friend, and each one has its own superpower. Think of it like choosing your woodworking sidekick – some are simple and reliable, while others are ready to tackle the toughest jobs. Let’s explore the lineup:

Plain Edge Joint (Butt Joint)

Okay, the butt joint. Sounds a bit cheeky, doesn’t it? It’s the simplest of the bunch – just two edges butted together, like giving each other a high-five. Super easy to pull off, especially if you’re in a hurry. But, and this is a big but(t), it’s not the strongest. It relies entirely on the glue. Think of it for light-duty stuff – maybe a back panel on a cabinet where there isn’t a lot of stress.

Reinforced Edge Joint

Now, if you like the ease of a butt joint but need more muscle, a reinforced joint is your jam. This is where you add some extra oomph with helpers like splines, dowels, biscuits, or even screws. These buddies add mechanical strength, so your joint doesn’t have to rely on just the glue. Consider it a “butt joint plus!”

Splined Joint

Ah, the elegant splined joint! It’s like giving your boards a secret handshake. You cut matching grooves in each edge and slip in a thin strip of wood (the spline). This significantly boosts strength and helps with alignment during glue-up.

Here’s the lowdown on creating one:

  1. Cutting the spline grooves: Use a router, table saw, or even a slot cutter to create precise grooves down the center of each edge. Accuracy is key here – you want a snug fit for the spline.
  2. Creating or purchasing splines: You can make your own splines from a contrasting wood for a visual pop, or buy them pre-made. Make sure they fit snugly but not too tightly in the grooves.
  3. Gluing and clamping the joint: Slather some glue in those grooves, insert the spline, and clamp everything together nice and tight. The spline gives the glue a ton of extra surface area to bond to, making a rock-solid joint.

Tongue-and-Groove Joint

Ever put together laminate flooring? Then you’re familiar with the tongue-and-groove! One board has a protruding “tongue,” and the other has a matching “groove.” When they fit together, they interlock like puzzle pieces. This joint is fantastic for alignment and offers a generous gluing surface. It’s especially useful for things like flooring, paneling, or even cabinet doors.

Rabbeted Joint

Finally, we have the rabbeted joint. A rabbet is simply a recess or channel cut along the edge of a board. This increases the surface area for gluing. By overlapping the edges, it creates a mechanical interlock that helps with alignment and adds strength. This technique is particularly good for frame and panel construction or anywhere you want a super solid edge.

Adhesives and Fasteners: Choosing the Right Combination

So, you’ve got your edges prepped, ready to become best buds and form one glorious, wide panel. But before you slather on just any old goo and start hammering things together, let’s talk about the unsung heroes of edge-to-edge joints: adhesives and fasteners. These guys are the key to a bond that’ll last longer than your questionable woodworking jokes. The right combination of glue and reinforcement can ensure that your hard work won’t fall apart (literally).

A. Wood Glue: The Classic Choice

Ah, wood glue – the reliable, old friend in every woodworker’s shop! There’s a whole family of these guys, each with its own quirks and strengths. The most common? Probably PVA (Polyvinyl Acetate), which is your everyday, reliable wood glue that cleans up with water. Then you’ve got the tougher guys like aliphatic resin, sometimes called yellow glue, known for its stronger initial tack and sandability.

But picking the right glue isn’t just about its name. It’s about understanding its personality. Think about open time – that’s the amount of time you have to assemble your joint after applying the glue. Choose a glue that gives you enough wiggle room (literally) without setting up too fast. Then there’s cure time – the time it takes for the glue to reach its full strength. Be patient, grasshopper! Clamping for the full cure time is essential for a strong bond.

B. Epoxy: The Gap-Filling Superhero

Got a slightly less-than-perfect joint? Don’t sweat it; epoxy is here to save the day! Unlike wood glue, epoxy is a fantastic gap-filler, making it ideal for those less-than-perfect scenarios. It’s also incredibly strong and waterproof, making it a great choice for outdoor projects or areas prone to moisture. It’s your go-to glue when strength and water resistance are paramount. It’s also the best choice for oily or resinous woods.

C. Polyurethane Glue: The Expanding Foam Friend

Polyurethane glue is the weird one in the group, but in a good way. It expands as it cures, filling gaps and creating a mechanical bond in addition to the adhesive bond. This makes it great for uneven surfaces or situations where you need extra grip. However, that expansion can also be a drawback – too much glue, and you’ll have a foamy mess to clean up! Best practice? Use it sparingly, and be prepared for some cleanup.

D. Fasteners: The Reinforcements

Sometimes, glue just needs a little help from its friends. That’s where fasteners come in! Screws, dowels, and biscuits can all be used in conjunction with glue to reinforce edge joints, providing extra strength and alignment, especially during the clamping process.

Screws, Dowels, and Biscuits:

  • Screws are great for adding clamping pressure while the glue dries, and they provide a very strong mechanical bond. Just be sure to countersink them and use wood plugs for a clean look.
  • Dowels are cylindrical pins that fit into pre-drilled holes, adding strength and alignment. They’re great for projects where you want a clean, fastener-free look.
  • Biscuits are oval-shaped pieces of compressed wood that swell when exposed to moisture (from the glue), creating a tight-fitting joint. They’re excellent for alignment and add a decent amount of strength.

When using any of these fasteners, be sure to space them appropriately – too close, and you risk weakening the wood; too far apart, and they won’t provide enough support. A good rule of thumb is to space them every 6-8 inches. Also, ensure your fasteners are properly aligned to prevent issues during assembly. Using jigs can assist in ensuring fastener alignment.

Tools and Techniques for Perfect Edge Joints

Perfect edge joints aren’t just about glue; it’s a *symphony of preparation and execution.* Let’s dive into the toolbox and the techniques that will turn you into an edge-joining virtuoso!

A. Jointing: Taming the Wild Edge

  • Forget the wonky edges! Jointing is your first line of defense against boards that refuse to cooperate. A jointer, whether a powered beast or a trusty hand plane, creates a perfectly flat and square edge. Think of it as giving your boards a much-needed haircut.

      • Jointer Technique: Feed the board over the cutter head, keeping downward pressure to ensure a consistent, flat surface. Overlap each pass by 50 percent, removing material until you have a flat surface that is flat against the outfeed table.
      • Hand Plane Technique: Use a long-soled hand plane to flatten and square the edge. Check for squareness with a reliable square, and adjust your technique accordingly.
  • Accuracy Tips: Take light passes, check for squareness often, and don’t rush. Patience is your friend here.

B. Planing: Smoothing the Path

  • Thickness matters! Planing ensures that your boards are not only flat but also the same thickness. This is crucial for a seamless final product. Whether you wield a power planer or a hand plane, the goal is consistent thickness and a silky-smooth surface.

    • Power Planer Technique: Set the planer to remove a very small amount of material with each pass. Multiple passes are better than trying to hog off too much at once.
    • Hand Plane Technique: Use a smoothing plane for a glass-like surface. Ensure your blade is razor-sharp for the best results.
  • Pro Tip: Alternate the direction you feed the board through the planer to minimize tear-out (especially with figured woods).

C. Table Saw: Precision Cuts

  • The table saw is your precision powerhouse for edge joining. It’s all about accuracy and safety. A wobbly cut here can throw off your entire project.

      • Safety First: Always use push sticks or push blocks. Never reach over the blade!
      • Technique: Use a sharp blade and a stable fence to guide your cuts. Aim for a smooth, consistent cut without burning.
  • Accuracy Boost: Double-check your fence settings and perform test cuts on scrap wood.

D. Clamping: The Pressure’s On!

  • Clamping is where the magic happens! It’s about applying even pressure to create a strong, gap-free bond. Think of it as giving your glue the best chance to shine.

    • Clamps and Cauls: Cauls are your secret weapon against warping. These are straight pieces of wood that you place between the clamps and your project to distribute pressure evenly.

      • Clamp Types: Bar clamps, pipe clamps, and parallel clamps are all great choices. Parallel clamps are particularly useful for keeping everything aligned.
      • Caul Placement: Position cauls above and below the joint, making sure they extend beyond the edges of the boards.
  • Even Pressure is Key: Don’t over-tighten the clamps! You want consistent pressure, not a crushed joint.

E. Surface Preparation: The Clean Slate

  • A clean surface is a happy surface! Proper surface preparation is crucial for a strong glue bond. You wouldn’t paint a dirty wall, would you? The same principle applies here.

    • Surface Preparation Techniques:

      • Sanding: Start with a coarser grit (120-grit) and work your way up to a finer grit (220-grit) for a smooth surface.
      • Cleaning: Wipe down the surfaces with a tack cloth or a clean cloth dampened with mineral spirits to remove dust and debris.
      • Moisture Content: Ensure your wood is acclimated to your shop’s humidity. Wood that’s too wet or too dry can lead to joint failure.

F. Hand Tools: The Finer Touch

  • Don’t underestimate the power of hand tools! They can be invaluable for fine-tuning your edge joints.

    • Block Plane: Perfect for chamfering edges or removing small imperfections.
    • Scraper: Ideal for smoothing out glue lines after the clamps come off.
    • Marking Gauge: Ensures parallel lines for consistent cuts or joinery.

Troubleshooting and Best Practices for Edge-to-Edge Joints: Taming the Wild Side of Wood

Let’s face it, sometimes woodworking feels less like crafting and more like wrestling a stubborn alligator. You’ve carefully prepped your wood, applied the glue with the precision of a brain surgeon, clamped everything within an inch of its life, and… BAM! Something goes wrong. Don’t worry, we’ve all been there. It’s time to delve into common problems and the Jedi master-level best practices to conquer them.

Common Problems: The Woodworking Gremlins

Wood, bless its natural heart, is a living, breathing thing (even after you cut it down). That means it’s prone to some interesting behavior. Here are a few common culprits that can derail your edge-to-edge jointing dreams:

Warping: When Your Wood Gets Bendy

  • What is it? Warping is like the wood’s rebellious phase. It comes in several delightful flavors:

    • Cupping: The board curves across its width, like a shallow bowl.
    • Bowing: The board curves along its length, like an archer’s bow.
    • Twisting: One corner lifts relative to the others, like a disgruntled dancer.
  • Why does it happen? Uneven moisture content is the usual suspect. One side of the wood dries faster than the other, leading to internal stresses.

  • How do you stop it?

    • Prevention: Acclimatize your wood! Let it hang out in your shop for a week or two before you start working with it, so it can adjust to the local humidity. Store wood flat and stickered (with thin strips of wood between layers) to allow air circulation.
    • Correction: Sometimes, you can flatten slightly warped boards with a jointer or planer. For severe warping, consider re-sawing the board or using it for smaller pieces where the warp won’t be as noticeable. Laminating thinner pieces together can also counteract warping.

Misalignment: The Leaning Tower of Tables

  • What is it? When the edges of your boards don’t line up perfectly, you’ve got misalignment. This is an eyesore and can compromise the joint’s strength.

  • Why does it happen? Careless prepping is usually to blame. Uneven edges, inconsistent clamping pressure, or a sneaky gremlin (see above) can all cause misalignment.

  • How do you stop it?

    • Prevention: Meticulous preparation is your best defense. Use a jointer and planer to create perfectly flat, square edges. Double-check your alignment before you tighten the clamps. Use cauls (pieces of wood clamped across the joint) to distribute clamping pressure evenly and prevent slippage.
    • Correction: If the misalignment is minor, you can sand it down after the glue dries. For more severe cases, you might need to re-saw the joint and start over.

Glue Squeeze-Out: A Sticky Situation

  • What is it? That lovely bead of glue that oozes out when you clamp the joint. It’s a sign of a good bond, but can be a pain to clean up.

  • Why does it happen? You used the right amount of glue (or maybe a little too much!).

  • How do you stop it (or at least manage it)?

    • Prevention: Apply glue evenly, but not excessively. Use a glue roller or brush for consistent coverage.
    • Cleanup: The key is to tackle the squeeze-out before it hardens completely. For water-based glues (like PVA), wipe it away with a damp cloth. For epoxy, use denatured alcohol. Let the glue partially dry until it becomes rubbery, then use a sharp chisel or scraper to pare it away. Avoid sanding wet glue, as it will gum up your sandpaper.

Joint Failure: The Woodworking Nightmare

  • What is it? When your joint falls apart. This can be catastrophic, especially if it happens after you’ve already applied a finish.

  • Why does it happen? A whole host of sins can lead to joint failure: poor joint design, inadequate glue coverage, insufficient clamping pressure, using the wrong type of adhesive for the application, or wood movement that was not accounted for.

  • How do you stop it?

    • Prevention: Plan your joint carefully. Choose the right joint type for the load it will bear. Use a high-quality adhesive and apply it generously. Use enough clamps to distribute pressure evenly. Account for wood movement in your design. Make sure your wood is properly seasoned and acclimatized.
    • Correction: Sadly, a failed joint usually means starting over. Analyze what went wrong and correct the problem before attempting the repair.

By understanding these common problems and implementing these best practices, you’ll be well on your way to mastering edge-to-edge joints and creating woodworking projects that are both beautiful and built to last! Now go forth and create!

Finishing and Refinement Techniques: From Functional to Fabulous!

Okay, so you’ve glued, clamped, and maybe even prayed a little – now it’s time to turn that edge-to-edge joint from a functional piece into a fabulous one! This is where the magic happens, where you transform a collection of boards into a seamless, professional-looking surface.

Sanding: Smooth Operator

Sanding isn’t just about making things feel nice; it’s about eliminating imperfections, creating a uniform surface, and preparing the wood to accept a finish beautifully. It’s like giving your wood a spa day!

  • Grit Progression: Start with a coarser grit (like 80 or 100) to knock down any significant bumps or unevenness. Then, gradually move to finer grits (120, 180, 220) to refine the surface. Think of it like sharpening a knife – each grit polishes a little more.
  • Sanding Blocks vs. Power Sanders: For smaller projects or detail work, sanding blocks give you incredible control. Wrap your sandpaper around the block, and let it do the work for you. For larger surfaces, a power sander (like an orbital sander) can save you a ton of time and elbow grease. Just be careful not to apply too much pressure, or you could end up with uneven spots.
  • Sanding with the Grain: Always sand with the grain of the wood. Going against the grain can leave scratches that are difficult to remove later.

Filling Gaps: Making Imperfections Disappear

Let’s face it; sometimes, despite our best efforts, those pesky little gaps just won’t go away. Don’t despair! Filling small gaps is a common practice, and it’s all about choosing the right material and technique.

  • Wood Filler: For smaller gaps, wood filler is your go-to solution. Choose a color that matches your wood or one that you can stain later. Apply the filler with a putty knife, pressing it firmly into the gap. Overfill slightly, as the filler tends to shrink as it dries. Once dry, sand it smooth with the surrounding surface.
  • Epoxy: For larger gaps or areas where you need extra strength, epoxy is your best bet. Epoxy is incredibly strong, durable, and can be tinted to match the wood color. Mix the epoxy according to the manufacturer’s instructions, and apply it to the gap. Epoxy tends to be a bit messier than wood filler, so use a disposable spreader and protect your work surface.
  • Color Matching: Take your time to find filler that matches the wood, use dyes or blending methods.

Finishing Touches

Remember, finishing and refinement are crucial steps in creating a high-quality edge-to-edge joint. Spend the time to get it right, and you’ll be rewarded with a beautiful, seamless surface that you can be proud of.

Environmental Considerations for Long-Lasting Joints

Okay, picture this: you’ve just finished a beautiful tabletop, the edge joints are perfectly flush, and you’re feeling like a woodworking rockstar. Fast forward a few months, and suddenly there’s a noticeable gap appearing. What gives? Blame it on Mother Nature, my friend!

Wood is a living, breathing material, and it’s constantly reacting to its environment, particularly humidity and temperature. Think of it like a sponge – it soaks up moisture when it’s humid and shrinks when it’s dry. This expansion and contraction can put a serious strain on your edge joints, leading to cracks, gaps, or even complete failure. So, how do we fight back against these wood-warping woes? Here’s the lowdown:

Proper Wood Selection: Choosing the Right Warrior

First things first: wood selection matters. Different species react differently to environmental changes. Denser, more stable woods like mahogany, walnut, or quartersawn oak are generally less prone to movement than softer, less stable woods like pine or poplar. Think of it as choosing the right soldier for the battle.

And just a friendly tip: Try to use boards that have been harvested in the region where the finished project will live. Local wood has already adapted to local conditions, giving it a head start in the long run!

Acclimatization: Letting Your Wood Get Comfortable

Think of it like this, if you went from Antarctica to the Sahara, your body would be in shock too. You need to give that wood a chance to chill. Acclimatization is the process of letting your wood adjust to the humidity and temperature of your shop (and eventually, its final destination) before you start working with it. This can take anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, depending on the size of the boards and the difference in environmental conditions.

Simply stack the boards in your shop with spacers between them to allow air to circulate, and let them sit. The goal is for the wood to reach its equilibrium moisture content (EMC), which is the moisture level it will naturally maintain in its environment. Patience is a virtue here!

Finishing Techniques: Sealing the Deal

A good finish isn’t just about looks; it’s also about protection. Finishes act as a barrier, slowing down the rate at which wood absorbs and releases moisture. This helps to minimize expansion and contraction, keeping your joints tight and happy.

Oil-based finishes penetrate the wood, providing good moisture resistance from within. Film-building finishes like lacquer or varnish create a harder, more durable surface that’s also highly water-resistant. For high-humidity environments, consider marine-grade finishes designed to withstand constant exposure to moisture.

Pro Tip: Apply finish evenly to all surfaces of the wood, including the underside and edges. This will create a balanced moisture barrier and prevent uneven expansion and contraction.

What are the primary advantages of employing edge-to-edge joints in woodworking projects?

Edge-to-edge joints provide significant advantages in woodworking, especially when creating wide panels. Woodworkers utilize edge-to-edge joints to combine two or more boards. These boards create a wider surface. The increased surface is ideal for tabletops. It also suits cabinet sides and other large-scale projects. The strength of the joint becomes a critical attribute. A strong joint ensures the panel remains flat. It also prevents warping or separation over time. This attribute is particularly important for projects subject to stress. Such projects include those exposed to changes in humidity. Aesthetic considerations also drive the use of edge-to-edge joints. These joints allow craftsmen to select boards with complementary grain patterns. These patterns create visually appealing surfaces. Careful matching of wood grain enhances the final product. It gives it a seamless, professional appearance. Edge-to-edge joints represent a versatile technique. This technique allows flexibility in design. It also provides structural integrity in woodworking applications.

What factors determine the selection of specific edge-to-edge jointing methods in woodworking?

Several factors influence the choice of edge-to-edge jointing methods. The woodworker considers the width and thickness of the boards. These dimensions impact the joint’s structural requirements. For thin boards, a simple butt joint with reinforcement may suffice. Thicker boards often necessitate stronger joints. Stronger joints include those with added surface area. These joints include tongue-and-groove or mortise-and-tenon joints. The type of wood also influences the decision. Softwoods might benefit from joints that offer more mechanical interlocking. This interlocking provides additional support. The anticipated stress on the joint is a critical factor. Tabletops require robust joints. The robust joints withstand daily use and potential weight. Aesthetic preferences also play a role. Some woodworkers prefer to minimize the visible joint line. They achieve this with precisely fitted, seamless joints. The available tools and equipment in the workshop are important. These determine which joints can be efficiently and accurately produced.

How does the preparation of wood edges influence the overall quality of an edge-to-edge joint?

Proper preparation of wood edges significantly affects the quality of edge-to-edge joints. Woodworkers must ensure the edges are perfectly straight. Straight edges guarantee tight, gap-free seams. Accurate alignment of the boards becomes possible with straight edges. The edges must also be square to the face of the board. Square edges prevent the panel from being uneven. Uneven panels require additional sanding. Additional sanding alters the final dimensions. A smooth surface is essential for a strong glue bond. Smooth surfaces allow the adhesive to adhere effectively. The adhesive creates a reliable connection between the boards. Woodworkers often use a jointer. They use it to create flat, square edges. Hand planing is another method. Hand planing achieves the same precision. Careful preparation results in a professional-looking joint. The joint exhibits superior strength and durability.

What role does clamping pressure play in the successful creation of an edge-to-edge joint?

Clamping pressure serves a vital role in the successful creation of edge-to-edge joints. Adequate pressure ensures the boards are held tightly together. This eliminates gaps along the joint line. The glue needs consistent contact between the surfaces. Consistent contact maximizes its adhesive properties. Insufficient pressure results in weak bonds. The weak bonds lead to joint failure over time. Excessive pressure squeezes out too much glue. This creates a glue-starved joint. Clamps should be evenly spaced along the joint. Even spacing distributes pressure uniformly. Woodworkers use various types of clamps. Bar clamps are suitable for long panels. Pipe clamps offer versatility. They accommodate different lengths. The correct clamping technique results in a strong, durable joint. The joint resists stress and maintains its integrity.

So, there you have it! Edge-to-edge joints aren’t as scary as they might seem. With a little patience and the right technique, you’ll be crafting seamless surfaces in no time. Now go get those boards joined!

Leave a Comment